Allowing Audio-Visual Recording to the Wrongful Dismissal Arbitration Grievance of Denis Rancourt

¯¯ 7$90;034-0 %4
 742
 
 ,90
 #0
 7-97,947,:/048 #  !& ,07 $0,3.00,3/& 99,,,07 33,73/03    :/4'8:,#0.47/341038#,3.4:7970;,3.07-97,9430,738 4220398
    #$ $ # & '$&# #$  %# &%   O 3,2087$90;034-0 147207705,.02039574108847 9390,.:941/:.,943,990&3;078941 99,,,89 .4397,.9,870;40/37085438094213,70;,3.0990 !& 970,7/94900,341/:.,943 80,.4397,.93 9,9,990259394.7.:2;03990!& ,700203979098  34 ,8,202-0741900307,5:-.9,/005390708935489 80.43/,70/:.,94354.,8970,908949088:041903:70,3/ 6:08943,-0,/23897,9;057,.9.0147803.3/8803931,.:9 93,3,9248507041 ,.,/02.1700/42  842093:3;0789 ,/23897,9438,7047394/7,2,9.,.:79,  O ,8479098/4.:20391742,-,.74:3/41473,85,7941 #4,4228843830700;079370.0;0/,3/574/:.0/ 974:901:3.94341,#4,4228843,82,/05:-. 974:0-8908799038:-28843807054890/ ,5:-. 8:-28843807070.47/0/97,38.7-0/849,9905:-.,/ 1:,..08894,9,82,/0,;,,-094904228843 ,3/ 908042288438/0,99,;,709415:-.3899:9438,3/ 743.47547,94380705708/0/4;07-,5:-.807;,393 90147241,4:79:/009 0700,;0,3,7-97,9439,9 ,8220/,90.4,0/380.70./08590905:-.3,9:704190 88:0,3/903899:9433;4;0/ O ,957080399398/4.:203987010.9;041297:0 94:98 ;,:08 4-807;,9438 -0018,3/453438 ,430 9 70,7/9490706:702039415:-./8.48:7041,/4.:20398 574/:.0/974:98,7-97,943574.088,3/90,:/4 70.47/3 419080574.00/383907039709 O /:.,9438 ,3/84:/,,8702,3 ,5:-.44/948:55479   ¯¯ /024.7,.
/3985:-.44/-03/,.43897:.90/2,39041 507;,8;0.47547,902,3,07,82:3/072308/024.7,. 0 /8,;43904;070235:-.3,9:7041 430785 41 90803899:9438 O 0 ,884.09 2:89,,8,803,3390708974:5/02,3/8 .038473,3/80.70. 4-030198,3/448084:9,903/8 ,70,.0;0/4857490.90/,3/44808 O ":9017,3084:/3 90;03-0,;3,3/8.:884343 .431/039,94745033088970,7/94,:/4 ;8:,70.47/3 90800,73847574/:.94341/4.:203981742090790:343 8 47:3;0789 88/0!7479 ,3/90/01,:9 84:/-0147 45033088 97,385,703. 5:-.,..4:39,-9 -0.,:809870,908 94907:33341,5:-.3899:943 5,/147-9,5,078,3/  3.70,83974:89:/0399:943,3.,71008
,:3;0789 O /43 90;039300;03300/942039439,9988,,3/2,7 .4:79.,80 .98 -0.,:809,98098:59,94325479,39 .4:7947,7-97,9430,7383;4;3:3;07890884:/-0 ,:/4 ;8:,70.47/0/%,9 8,1,80/.4942,7-97,943 ,3/.4:79574.088083;4;3:3;07890884:/-070.47/0/ -0.,:800;07939,98574/:.0/974:,5:-.3899:943 - 983,9:70 702,384784:/702,33905:-./42,3:3088 907088420570883300/,74:3/507843,57;,.9,9300/894 -0,//70880/ ,3/9857;,.300/2:89-04;07023 84394-0706:70/ ,8,30.05943  %907:0   #%#% #  O 49900254078/0,3/90:3438/0,/,700/3793 9,9,:/4;8:,70.47/3884:/-0,40/
1478420-,770 70,84390,7-97,947 43843 039,,3899080841-49 5,7908%88098,974:-3570.0/03941 -495,7908-0/,230/
 ,5:-.807;,39348,9 8-089 49,3,:85.4:8-0333 O %0,7-97,9478,5:-.807;,39 .20,389,9,94:0 ,8,..4:39,-99490 39,74,-4:7#0,94384,7/ #  870,9089,..4:39,-9894905045045,88,,7 90 9,5,35:-. O %0!:-.,894-0,703 43430,3/90:3;0789 705708039,9;088:0899,9/4.:2039857080390/,90,738 -05:-. -:990390,7-97,947:3,907,/0./0894-4. ,:/4 ;8:,70.47/3415:-.0,73849,4390 70.47/3410,738-4.8902,35:-. /4.:20398-03 57080390/,90,738 1471:97,385,703.9080/4.:20398 84:/-08.,330/,3/039070/4394,300.9743.20/:2147 5:-./434,/ %8882,79490:3;0789025407841,   ¯¯ 5:-.3899:94397394.43897:.9.079,3,850.98,8.431/039, ,3/57;,9049,439070.47/3415:-.0,738070 /4.:20398,70-032,/05:-.,;0908,200110.941349 2,390/4.:2039839017895,.08:850.99,9 890 :3;0789705708039,9;08 450  &'#$%  %%#!#$%%'$  O %0.431/039,9,74:3/574/:.94341/4.:2039870,90894, 290/.47547,9439,95708:2,-,8.42207.,390708989,9 9,3989457490.9174298.42509943398389,3.0 41.4:780  ,0;041.431/039,9300/894089 .4:/00903/ 94900,738349-035:-.70.47/0/ 940903/90 57490.94341.431/039,9%0&3;078941 99,,8349, 57;,90.47547,943 342,990742:.!708/039#4.,3/90 &3;0789/23897,9439794.43897:.990&3;078939,9 ,&3;0789,/23897,9478.,3349050.99,9.431/039,9 ,3/,.415:-.,..088940,73884:/-0903472$25 5:9 90&3;078941 99,,8349,.47547,943 98,7907 .420817429050450974:90!74;3.,4;0732039 9,9 .,3-080/0/-.431/039,9,3/57;,./02,3/8
90 &3;0789824703309,349 147 57419422:3903970 9,98:3/07.4389,395:-.,3/4;0732039,8.7:93 &3;0789,/23897,9478 3.:/30,.4:380,3/!708/039 #4.,703498,704/078 347.47547,9043078
90,70 .,709,07847.:894/,3841905:-.44/,3/3;08920393 0/:.,9435,/147-.90383/,8.,709,078 9084:/-0 4507,939905708:259439,90;079390/4 47 /4.:2039890574/:.0 ,3/84:/.420:3/075:-. 8.7:93%05708:2594384:/-09,90;0793-05:-. ,3/43974:0.0594389,9,7084390708,300/147 57;,.,3/.431/039,9-0970,90//1107039%0 :3;0789705708039,9;08,708002397394970,90;0793 ,8.431/039,,3/ 90701470 84:/349-084394905:-.  90.059438-032,/01477,70389,3.08-03574/:.0/147 5:-.70;0 O $:5570884341,:/4;8:,70.47/3847839,3/029, .425:8;04703147.0/.431/039,941/4.:203989,902,3,90 1742,5:-.3899:94384:/825-0.425090/8,40/ O 431/039,9706:7020398,7035,.0948,10:,7/57;,90 .47547,90/0,38 5745709,7340/0 .42207.,574/:.98 ,3/574.08808  %905:-.574.08808 57494.48,3/ /4.:20398574/:.0/-9050450 83899:943
90&3;0789 O :3;07898349,57;,90.47547,943 342,990742:.   ¯¯ 3/4/708838,550/94,.,/02.574.08808- 574108843,  2,3,078,3/,/23897,9478%,98349948, 94: 9,9,8 .,709,07890/4349,;0,1/:.,77085438-9948,10:,7/ 90504508 390708983985:-.3899:943%02489.079,3 /4,3/84:/-0.,0/94,..4:39039384,740;07  9043,905:-..,3-0314720/410393847438 974:4343/0 45035:-./8.48:70%043,90 5:-..,3349,9,/23897,9478,70/439074-8974: .4393:,5:-./8.48:7041984507,9438%0!:-.84:/349 ,3/.,334970840439047/41,/23897,94784,;0 ,8 ,33907089 907433899:943,5407,3/3907089841801 57490.943%0!:-.,894-0.421479,-099074041 ,/23897,9478974:984370;041,/23897,9478 ,.9438 %043,9,9.,3-0,.0;0/8974:45033088  97,385,703. ,..4:39,-9 ,..0889439073,/4.:20398,3/ 70.47/38410,738,3/200938 &3;078908,701:3/0/974:9,5,078 /4,78,3/3.70,83 ;07/70.9174289:/0399:943,3/,3.,71008 &3;0789,/23897,9478,3/090897942,3:1,.9:7090280;08 ,3/9077408,8.47547,9043078454880885745709,7 31472,943%0,703 9,3/90/43 9:3;078982470330 9,349 147 57419422:39039709,3,47547,9438 8:. ,/23897,9478,70.:894/,38478,10:,7/841,5:-.,8809 147905:-.44/49390:3;0789090/484:/-0 .431/039,,3/805,7,90174290504509,91:3/90;07 08903.041:3;078908,3/90;044/841:3;07890908  1,.:9,3/89,11 &3;07890908,3/,:94790884:/-0.43/:.9390,11,7841 ,:3;0789990,88:259439,9905:-..,33850.9, 70.47/8 0.05914790507843,31472,943413/;/:,8 9,9 5079,394904507,943419,9:3;0789%4050.99,98420 70.47/8,70.431/039,/408349199905:-.3,9:704190 473841,:3;0789%070,70842070.47/89,9,7057;,90 147507843,70,8438 -:9349.431/039,1474507,943, .438/07,943 &3;07890908,70,..4:39,-094909,5,35:-.,3/9490 ;0789:/039845,147900/:.,943,807;.0$9:/0398,70 0,73078,3/89,04/078 349.0398484:/349-057;94 .431/039,.42207.,31472,943,3/390708983.70,83  :3;07890908,.90,:94.7,9.5,70398943.70,83 31,390/89:/0398 703/070/70,9;05407088
:38003,3/ :30,7/:39070.47/34190800,7384:/-0,3 090384341343,9 8-08914790,.,/02..422:39 ,80/435747894708,3/050703.087054790/949020/,,-4:9 O O O O O   ¯¯ 90&3;0789 ,.,/02.0908,3/,/23897,9478 ,70574-,- :30,89.079,389:,9438 /00/8 02,8 09.-032,/0 5:-.-0.,:809080 549039, .4:/02-,77,88 31,20 38:9 47:3/0723090705:9,9434190:3;0789 90280;084790 5:-.":9017,3
94:&3;07890908,;0-0037:333 90:3;078909074357;,90.47547,903/429 8349 90789 84:78 905:-. 8 O 395.,0,80941,3/ 90:3;0789,0788:0893 0;0743089,3.431/039,98074:8-0.,:800;07430 -00;089,9.431/039,90898,3/9,992:89-08,10:,7/0/  ":9017,3 .431/039,98-032,3:1,.9:70/9457490.990 390708984190:3;0789%0800,7382:8989,791742, 5489434145033088 97,385,703. 5:-.,..4:39,-9,3/903 030.059438,7809,929300/94702,3.431/039,  90800.05943884:/-09474:70;00/94038:709,99,9 890-089,;03:0949,0 ,3/907,943,0147.431/039,9 2:89-02,/05:-.%08,204/897:0147900,738 90280;08%0/01,:95489432:89-09,990800,7382:89 -0,:/4 ;8:,70.47/0/-0.,:809 83905:-. 8390708994/4 843/9,9 890178939070899,984:/-057490.90/ O %0:3;0789705708039,9;08/080023897394 2,3:1,.9:70,8479841 .431/039, ,850.9893,5:-. 3899:943%07083493.431/039,,-4:9,:3;0789 8 4507,9438%070,7057;,90 507843,70.47/89,9 35,79 2:89 -00593.431/03.0 -:99080,70390406:90,93 5479434190/4.:20398 0307,90/-,:3;0789 ,3/84:/-0 970,90/,80.0594387,9079,3903472  !&  &%$$ %  #!#$%%'$ O ,80/43243050703.08 90!& 47,.:9884.,943  83496:9090,97:89.-4/997089454797,9807;08 97002,8907880984139070898 .,99208.4203.431.9 9430,34907%017892,8907 478094139070898 890 :3;0789,/23897,943-0.,:809080705708039,9;08,705,/ 974:90:3;0789,3/9 8390!& 83907089894005907 70,94385990:3;0789,/23897,9434507,9370,9;0 82449 O %080.43/2,8907 478094139070898 8 839070898/70.9 %0 :89,890:3;0789705708039,9;08/0 549039,800 948,10:,7/90739070898,3/,;4/02-,77,882039,3/5:-. 8.7:93 O %097/2,8907 478094139070898 890 8/:994,8889 3/;/:,202-078%01789942,89078 4780984139070898 ,70 9930/
9897/2,8907 478094139070898 82:.0,07   ¯¯ ,3/290/-0.,:80901789949,02:.0757479,3/,8 ,894/ 90.40.9;09,082:.07574799,33/;/:, 39070898 O ;039807,7.41 ,99208.431.93 39070898,;390 0,73870.47/0/1475:-.8.7:9300590:343 8,.9438 :3/0770;0,3/247097,385,7039,3/,..4:39,-013/9 /005974:-39,990:343 147389,3.0 ,8,700/9,93430 41900,738-097,38.7-0/%7,38.75943807089,3/,7/ 574.0/:70,9#4,42288438-0.,:8019070070,3/85:908 ,894,94..:770/,957470,738 9097,38.7598.4:/-0 /7,3:54394.,71574.088 0,.947/3410.,308 09.%4 7024;0,,07415:-.70.47/2,0820;078:85.4:8,894 988-03706:0890/,3/988-03,700/94  %&'#$%  O 489:3;0789083,3,/, ,705:-.1:3/0/974:9,5,07 1:3/3,3/89:/0399:943,3.,71008 90,99072,3:5,3 3.70,83574547943414507,943,1:3/3 88:. 0;0793 43433,5,79.:,7:3;07892:89-0.43897:0/,89,3 5,.03,5:-. 34957;,9080993 2,,8,2,0/,94 :3;0789,/23897,94384733905:-.80993.4393:, 9794.43897:.9;,74:8,850.98415:-.:3;07894507,9438,8 57;,90  5,79.:,7948000203989,94/90549039,147 0;08418.7:93 5749089476:08943-90,7075:-. 49384:/-0.431/039,4757;,90 0.059384,90/ .7.:289,3.08070-507843,57;,90/09,8 8:.,80,9 .43/9438 84:/702,3.431/039, 7,3,943,574.08808 47.47708543/03.0,70349.431/039,-0.,:8090/0,990 5:-.3899:943 857494.4843897:.94341.079,3,850.9841, :3;0789,8 57;,90 ,874498390.431/039,94157;,90 .47547,9438 842093 574108843, 2,3,07,89 ,/23897,94789794148943945:-.3899:9438,8 3472,  4507,93574.0/:708 O 700/4241$500. 700/42415708843,3/700/424190 !7088,3/ 9070/, %080,701:3/,2039,1700/4287,390/ 940,.,3/0;07,3,/,3:3/0790,790741#98,3/ 700/428%4,7-97,7.0384790801700/428 ,890,7-97,947 ,8/4309900,7343.431/039,98/8:893,3/ 84890.425090,.4170,7/14790801700/428%080 1700/4282:89,84-04-807;0/970,7/9490:3;0789 8 /02,3/147.431/039,9.93,2,3:1,.9:70/300/9457490.9 ,/23897,943 874037:333,5:-.3899:943 O .,/02.700/42  174290&%0-890
.,/02.1700/42   ¯¯ 89010-44/419024/073:3;07899890799490,.  0,73 89:/,3/5:-81700414794/447970,94170578,,3/ /8.723,94393.:/08907994.79.090:3;0789,3/ 9079945,79.5,903984;073,3.0%03:70574;/08, 14:3/,943147,.,/02.1700/42-038:739,9,.,/02.89,11 .,3349-0/82880/94:9:89.,:80,3/7474:8/:0574.088 O 8.4:780,3/79.,0-,90 70,90/94,.,/02.1700/42890 300/9403,035:-./8.4:780,3/.79.,/0-,90948088:08 9,9,70700;,399490.,/02!:-.173, 0,7 574108847481:903:70/:3/076:08943,-0574.088088 /70.9700;,399490-74,/07.,/02. /:.,943,,3/0307, .422:3908%80584/09390&3;078941 99,, ,;0/70.90110.9:543,.,/02.1700/42 1700/4284105708843 ,3/903:7054.1470,7894.420$9:/0398,3/5741088478,0 300/94,;0,2,907,,783174290800,738,;,,-094 9029403,03/0-,90,3//8.4:780,85,7941902:.,707 0/:.,943,5740.9 O 70,907.422:395:-.44/8:554798/024.7,. /:.,943 ,3/5:-./8.4:780,7090.47307894308147/024.7,.94089 3,,70,3/0/:.,90/.9037,70,9907449841/024.7,9. 1700/428%0708.:7703957490893 ,.7488
.4:39708 90 ..:50/4;020399,9 35,79 88:08939,9900908 /.9,939490

.4224314 0;0394:90

.42243 14,701:3/390090 ,894,91:3/,2039,1700/428,70 ,3/490-0290/7:,- 2,3,9900,739,-0 705708039904190545:,94398,,7080.00/3  5070,790394803905:-.,:/03.0,990 .,3,3/.,3349/4 0;0394: 1472489,/23897,9478 907 8,,708,70.423174290504509 89209,99050450,70 0,7/,3/907808,701440/ ,3/9,93.:/08,;3 9080 ,3/,:3;0789.4:79,3/,7-97,9430,738-0 349 432,/05:-. -:99,9,-0,:/4 ;8:,70.47/0/ :3;078980,5:-..422:39.039700/397:8914790 50450
90,703490;03.480949,941,57;,90.47547,943  0.05939023/8410989 1:3.943,7 5:-.807;,39 .:894/, ,/23897,9478:7907 9,9,9047,,3/799038:-288438 70,9394907084:/4784:/349-070.47/38419080 0,73884:/-02,/05,7941905:-.70.47/419080 0,738:7907 ,,7-97,9473490884:/-02,/05:-.,3/ ,0,73884:/-097,38.7-0/ $&# #$ $ O 8.,3-08003 9070,70,3:2-0741,03/,8 //03,3/34984//03  4507,93.43.:770391742-498/08419888:0,3/84940059080,03/,8 05.9,3/35:-.;0,3/450394.796:0 9070300/894-02:950,:/4 ;8:,70.47/389,9.,3-070;00/43,34343-,88:7907 9080   ¯¯ O 0,73884:/,;097,38.75943841,988,/-,5,7908849,99070.,3 -070,9075:-.8.7:93,3//8.4:780,74:3/90.0397,88:084198 ,7-97,943 :3;07898,5:-.44/-038,10:,7/0/,3/0/397:8994,74:541 5:-.,/23897,94784,7090.:894/,3841903899:9438 34957;,90 .47547,90430783/0,38990:3;0789090,3/,/23897,9478,;0 948/09905:-. 8390708981789 34939073,0254008 %0800,738,70,3090384341,/,4:08.:770394..:7739390 :3;0789 -74,/07,.,/02. 4.,,3/3,943,.422:3908 %88901789.,8041983/3,3,/, 90 7431: /8288,41,903:70/ 1:574108847-0.,:8041,.,/02.70,8438 .1083901,.04125.91: ,.,/02.1700/4285741088478,708:55480/9403493:3;0789809938  98,,3/2,7.,809,9,83,943,,3/,7:,-39073,943,70507.:88438 14790.,/02 2470-74,/ &308420447,57080390/,9900,7343 .94-07   ,2349 ,8347706:0893478:08939,9907084:/-0,:/4 ;8:,70.47/3841 900,7384190038#,3.4:7970;,3.07-97,943 /02,3/9,99080 0,7382:89-0,:/4 ;8:,70.47/0/,3/9,9,3,74145033088  97,385,703. 5:-.,..4:39,-9-05708:20/4;079,941.431/039,9,3/ 70897.935:-.,..088%884:/3 90;03-08420-0,-4:70//8.:8843 O O O    %,34:14770,/328:-28843,3/;391:.438/07,943  7$90;034-0